Ryan Nichols
Behind the scenes

Label the Fake Stuff Fake

Invented testimonials and stock logos read as fake because they are never specific. Two fixes: label the sample, and make one real thing real.

By Ryan Nichols

  • 2 total reach
  • 0 reading now0 active 24h
  • 0 shares0 inbound
  • 0 comments

Every business owner building a new site hits the same wall.

The page needs content. The business does not have it yet.

No testimonials, because you have four customers and you have not asked them. No case studies, because the work is three months old. No numbers worth printing, because the numbers are small.

So you fill it.

A stock photo of a smiling team in a glass conference room that is not your team and not your conference room. A line that says trusted by 500+ businesses. Three five star reviews signed with initials. A logo bar of companies you have never invoiced.

I understand exactly why people do it. An empty page feels like an admission. Filling it feels like progress.

It is not progress. It is the fastest way to lose somebody who was almost ready to call you.

Here is the reason, and it is not a moral one. Your visitor has seen ten of these pages this week. They cannot articulate what tipped them off, but something did, and the tell is always the same. Nothing on the page is specific. Five hundred businesses is not a number, it is a texture. J.M., verified customer, is not a person. The smiling team has no names under it.

Specific is the only thing that reads as true. And invented content is never specific, because the person inventing it has nothing specific to invent from.

There are two moves, and you can do both this week.

The first is to label the sample as a sample. If you are showing what the product will look like full, say the word demo on the thing. Not in the terms of service. On the card, where the eye lands.

I do this on my own marketplace build. Every listing tile on the Gideon Commerce home page carries the word Demo before the product name, and the footer on every page says Demo build in plain text. That is not modesty. It is so that nobody can ever come back and say I showed them a catalog and let them believe it was sales.

The second move is harder and it is the one that actually works. Replace one fake thing with one real small thing.

One customer, first name and town, one sentence of what they actually said to you on the phone. One photo of the actual truck with the actual dent in the bumper. One number you can defend if somebody asks where it came from, even if that number is four.

Four is not embarrassing. Four with a name attached beats five hundred with nothing attached, every single time, because four is checkable and five hundred is not.

The fear underneath all of this is that small looks weak. It does not. Small looks early. Early is a stage. Fake is a character judgment, and once a visitor makes it about your character they are gone and they are not writing to tell you why.

If your site is currently carrying invented proof, do not panic and blank the page. Pick the one item a customer is most likely to lean on, and make that one item real. Then the next one. The page gets slower to build and much harder to argue with.

Read next

Fighting Shadows · Pre-order

Early access for $17.76$29.9941% off

Read it first and own a piece of the story — or become a Founding Supporter (limited to 250).

Don't lose this story to an algorithm.

The next chapter gets posted here first — on my own domain, where no platform can throttle it and no one can ban it. Drop your email or number and the update reaches you the moment it's live.

Email gets one confirmation click. Unsubscribe anytime. No spam, no selling your data — ever.

Tap how this hits you — no signup, everyone sees the count

Share this post — get it back in front of people

Comments

Speak here

Create an account to comment.

This is where people can say what gets buried or cancelled elsewhere. Comments are signed-only, moderated, and tied to a real profile so the record stays usable.

No approved comments yet. Create an account and put the first opinion on the record.