Public January 6 profile · ready to claim

David Mehaffie

Pardoned January 6 defendant

David Mehaffie, identified by the FBI as AFO number 86, in an archived January 6 evidence frameDocumented editorial-use image
FBI AFO #86 image page preserved by Lawfare from the Internet Archive; display image cropped where needed, metadata stripped and normalized to JPEG for this archive Published for archive identification and reporting; reuse rights are not represented as cleared.Image source →

David Mehaffie is a Kettering, Ohio man in his sixties, a longtime figure in the Dayton area whose January 6 case was pardoned in 2025. FACT: On January 6, 2021, Mehaffie was near the Lower West Terrace tunnel, one of the most contested spots at the Capitol. After a bench trial before Judge Trevor McFadden that ran August 29 to September 7, 2022, he was found guilty on four counts, two felonies (aiding and abetting the assault of officers, and interfering with law enforcement during a civil disorder) and two misdemeanors. He was found not guilty of obstruction of an official proceeding. (Sources: Dayton Daily News; DOJ; WHIO.) FACT: He was sentenced February 24, 2023, to 14 months incarceration, 24 months of supervised release, a $220 special assessment, and $2,000 restitution. FACT: On January 20, 2025, President Trump granted clemency to January 6 defendants. (Source: PBS NewsHour.) The investigation drew on security camera footage and tips passed to the FBI, and a bench trial let the judge weigh that evidence directly rather than a jury. Mehaffie pleaded not guilty to every count and was acquitted of the top obstruction charge. (FACT: D.D.C. docket) Charges are charges, and the court's findings stand in full below. This profile does not argue the verdict. It gives Mehaffie and his family a place to add the rest, who he is at home, in his community, in his own words, if they choose to claim it. WHERE THINGS STAND: David Mehaffie is pardoned, his sentence complete, back in Kettering. CASE RECORD Case No. 1:21-cr-40, U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia. Arrested 8/12/21. Arraigned 8/17/21, pleaded not guilty to all counts. Bench trial 8/29/22-9/7/22. Found guilty on four counts 9/13/22; not guilty of obstruction. Sentenced 2/24/23 to 14 months incarceration, 24 months supervised release, $2,000 restitution. Full pardon 1/20/25. This profile is unclaimed. If this is you, or your family, claiming it is free, forever.

The case file

On the record

Case number
1:21-cr-40
Court
U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia
Disposition
Arrested 8/12/21. Arraigned 8/17/21, pleaded not guilty to all counts. Bench trial held 8/29/22-9/7/22 before Judge Trevor McFadden. Found guilty 9/13/22 on four counts, two felonies (aiding and abetting assault of officers, interfering with law enforcement during a civil disorder) and two misdemeanors; found not guilty of obstruction of an official proceeding. Sentenced 2/24/23 to 14 months incarceration, 24 months supervised release, $2,000 restitution.
Arrested
August 12, 2021

Charges

  • Assaulting, Resisting or Impeding Certain Officers and Aiding and Abetting
  • Obstruction of an Official Proceeding and Aiding and Abetting
  • Civil Disorder
  • Disorderly Conduct in a Capitol Building
  • Act of Physical Violence in the Capitol Grounds or Buildings

Sentence

14 months incarceration; 24 months supervised release; $220 special assessment; $2,000 restitution

Public knowledge · no paywall

This profile is free for anyone to read.

Sign-in is only required to claim ownership, manage a claimed profile, or suggest a factual correction. Reading and sharing the public record never requires an account.

A free account is required for either action so submissions remain tied to a real person and can be reviewed.

11views0shares

Tap how this hits you. No signup, everyone sees the count

Connection to United States v. Nichols

David Mehaffie appears in the record of United States v. Nichols. The full case (timeline, people, documents) is public and free.

Walk the whole case →

Evidence on file

No scans linked yet

No scans linked to this entry yet. Curating is ongoing. Check back.