No Water, No Tax? Texas SB 399 Only Works in One County
SB 399 would let cities and counties fully exempt homesteads with no utility drinking water. The population bracket fits only Dallas County. Read it.
By Ryan Nichols
- 312 total reach
- 0 reading now•2 active 24h
- 0 shares•0 inbound
- 0 comments
No clean water from a utility. A full tax bill anyway. A new Texas bill would fix that, but only if you live in one county.
Plain English summary
Senate Bill 399 was filed on November 16, 2026. It would let a city or a county wipe out its property tax on certain homesteads that do not get drinking water piped in from a water utility.
Not a cut. The whole appraised value. Zero city tax, zero county tax on that home, if the local government votes to offer it.
Here is the catch. The bill only works in a county with between 2.6 million and 4.5 million people. By the Census Bureau's own numbers, that is Dallas County. Nobody else.
Why it matters
There are Texans right now who pay for roads, deputies, and county services and still cannot turn on a faucet and drink what comes out.
If the Legislature thinks that family deserves a break, I agree with the idea.
But a family on a private well in Upshur County or Marion County would get nothing from this bill. Not because their situation is different. Because their county is too small.
Same state. Opposite rule.
The receipt
FACT: SB 399 was filed 11/16/2026 by Sen. West. The caption reads: "Relating to a local option exemption from ad valorem taxation by a municipality or county of the total appraised value of certain residence homesteads that do not have access to potable drinking water." (Texas Legislature Online)
FACT: The bill adds Section 11.137 to the Tax Code. To qualify, a homestead must be:
- in a county with a population of 2.6 million or more and less than 4.5 million
- in a census tract with no more than 10,000 people, a median household income of no more than $60,000, and no more than 2,500 households
- without access to potable drinking water supplied directly to the property by a retail public utility
FACT: The exemption covers the total appraised value of the homestead, from taxes by a municipality or county, only if that city or county adopts it. School district taxes are not in the bill.
FACT: Once granted, the owner does not have to reapply every year. The bill adds Section 11.137 to the list in Tax Code Section 11.43(c).
FACT: The bill takes effect January 1, 2028, and only if Texas voters approve a constitutional amendment proposed in the 2027 session. If voters say no, the bill does nothing.
FACT: Census Bureau county figures put Dallas County at 2,611,995 at the April 2020 base and Harris County at 4,731,433. Tarrant County was 2,110,999. Gregg County was 124,301. (Census Bureau county population totals)
DOCUMENTED INFERENCE: By those numbers, Dallas County is the only Texas county inside the 2.6 million to 4.5 million window. Harris is too big. Tarrant is too small.
DOCUMENTED INFERENCE: News outlets including KERA and The Dallas Morning News have reported for years on Sand Branch, a community in southeast Dallas County without running water. The bill does not name Sand Branch or any community.
DOCUMENTED INFERENCE: As written, the water test is about utility service, not water quality. A home on a private well that meets the other tests would appear to qualify.
NEEDS AUTHENTICATION: I did not find the companion constitutional amendment on Texas Legislature Online as of this run. It may be filed later.
What Ryan says
RYAN STATEMENT: I am not against helping a family that has no clean water coming to the house. If government is going to tax you for services, and you cannot even get water to your kitchen sink, that tax bill ought to come down.
What I am against is writing the law so it only fits one place.
That is what a population bracket does. It sounds neutral. "Counties with 2.6 million to 4.5 million people." But there is one county in that box. Everybody in Austin knows it.
Plenty of East Texas homes run on a private well. Out here that is normal. If the Legislature believes a homestead without utility water deserves relief, then write the rule for every Texan who meets it. Gregg. Harrison. Smith. Marion. Upshur. All of us.
One state. One rule.
And remember who pays when a county exempts a home completely. The road still gets graded. The deputy still answers the call. Somebody else picks up that share. That is a decision your county commissioners should make in the open, with the numbers on the table.
Show me the map of who qualifies. Show me what it costs. Then let's talk.
What this does not prove
It does not prove the bill was written for any one neighborhood. The text names no community.
It does not prove the bill will pass, or that voters will approve the amendment it depends on.
It does not prove any city or county would adopt the exemption. It is local option.
It does not prove how many homes would qualify. I have not seen a count.
What it does prove
It proves the bill, as filed, only reaches homesteads in a county with 2.6 million to under 4.5 million people.
It proves the Census Bureau's numbers put only Dallas County in that range.
It proves the break would be total, city and county only, and only if local leaders choose it.
It proves rural East Texas families without utility water are not covered by this version.
The bottom line
The idea has a heart. The bracket does not.
If no water from a utility is a good enough reason for tax relief in Dallas County, it is a good enough reason in Marion County.
Write it for everybody, or explain why not.
This is the record.
Do not threaten anyone. Do not harass anyone. Do not contact anyone in my name. Read it. Share it. Send receipts, evidence, witnesses. Put eyes on the record.
You made it to the end
Most people quit at the headline. You didn’t.
So don’t stop here. Pick one.
Read the book
Fighting Shadows is the whole story in my own words: the road into January 6, the D.C. jail, and the fight to get the record out.See the book
Follow the case
The record is still being written. Get one email when something new drops on it.
Hire Ryan
I built this site. Want one that brings your business real leads? Start with a free 30-minute call.See the services
Tap how this hits you. No signup, everyone sees the count
312
Views
0
Likes
0
Comments
0
Shares
Share it. Every share puts more eyes on the record.



Comments
Speak here
Create an account to comment.
This is where people can say what gets buried or cancelled elsewhere. Comments are signed-only, moderated, and tied to a real profile so the record stays usable.
No approved comments yet. Create an account and put the first opinion on the record.