HB 1146: The Paper Is the Receipt. Let Us Count It.
HB 1146 and SB 84 would limit Texas no-ground recounts to paperless machines, after state law required paper records starting with 2026 elections.
By Ryan Nichols
- 71 total reach
- 0 reading now•0 active 24h
- 0 shares•0 inbound
- 0 comments
Texas spent five years putting paper behind every vote.
Now a bill would make it harder to ask for that paper to be counted.
One word does it. Paperless.
Plain English summary
Right now, Texas law says a candidate does not need a reason to get a recount of electronic voting system results. No close margin required. No sworn statement required. You file the petition, you pay the deposit, you get the recount.
HB 1146, filed November 13 by Rep. Richard Raymond, adds one word to that rule. The free pass would apply only to "paperless" electronic voting systems. Its Senate twin, SB 84 by Sen. Judith Zaffirini, was filed November 9. Same text.
Here is the problem. Since September 1, 2026, Texas law says the machines have to make paper.
Why it matters
In 2021 the Legislature passed SB 598. It said voting machines used after September 1, 2026, must create a paper record the voter can read. It said that paper is the official record for a recount. It passed the Senate 31 to 0 and the House 136 to 8.
So the state built the paper trail. Then a bill shows up that keeps the no-reason recount only for machines that do not have one.
If most Texas machines now print paper, the no-reason recount covers a small corner of the map. Everyone else would need a ground. A close margin. A small race. A sworn statement from an election judge.
That is a real change to how you check an election in Texas. It deserves a hearing in the open, with the authors on the record saying why.
The receipt
FACT: HB 1146 (90th Legislature) by Raymond was filed 11/13/2026. It amends Election Code Section 212.0241, the "no ground required" recount rule, to add the word "paperless" to the heading and to subsections (a), (b) and (c). It takes effect September 1, 2027. Bill text
FACT: Bill history lists SB 84 by Zaffirini as an identical companion. SB 84 was filed 11/09/2026. HB 1146 history, SB 84 history
FACT: The Secretary of State's recount guide says no ground is required for a recount of electronic voting system results, under Section 212.0241. Other grounds include a margin under 10 percent of the winner's votes, a race with fewer than 1,000 total votes, or a sworn statement from an election judge about a paper ballot count. A deposit is required with the petition. SOS recount procedures
FACT: SB 598 (87th Legislature) by Kolkhorst took effect 9/1/2021. It added Election Code Section 129.003, requiring direct recording electronic machines to be auditable voting systems with a voter-readable paper record, and making that paper the official record for a recount. Those rules apply to elections held on or after September 1, 2026. It also set risk-limiting audits for statewide races after August 31, 2026. SB 598 enrolled text, SB 598 history
FACT: HB 1146 does not define "paperless electronic voting system."
DOCUMENTED INFERENCE: Because SB 598 requires paper records from the 2026 elections forward, HB 1146 would leave the no-ground recount for very few Texas machines. Most candidates would need one of the other grounds.
NEEDS AUTHENTICATION: Whether Section 129.003 has been changed since 2021, and whether any Texas county still runs a paperless system. I did not pull the current code text or a county equipment list for this article.
What Ryan says
RYAN STATEMENT: The paper is the receipt. Texas fought for that receipt. The Senate voted 31 to 0 for it.
Now that we have it, I do not want the receipt locked in a drawer.
If a candidate is willing to put up the deposit and wants the paper counted, count the paper. Sunlight is cheap. Doubt is expensive.
Maybe the authors have a reason. Maybe the audits do the job now. Fine. Say it in committee. Show the numbers. How many no-reason recounts were filed? What did they cost the counties? Did any of them change a result?
Show me the evidence. Then we talk about closing the door.
What this does not prove
It does not prove anyone wants to hide anything. I do not know the authors' reasons, and I am not guessing at them.
It does not prove no-reason recounts were being abused. I have no numbers on how often they are used.
It does not prove the bill will move. It was just filed. No hearing. No vote.
What it does prove
Two identical bills, one in each chamber, would shrink a recount right that exists in Texas law today.
The state already requires paper. This bill would tie the easiest recount to machines with no paper.
That is in the text. The record does not lie.
Bottom line
Paper behind the vote was the deal. Counting that paper when a candidate asks, and pays, should stay part of the deal.
Watch HB 1146 and SB 84. Watch where your own representative lands. The authors should explain it on the record.
Count the paper.
Do not threaten anyone. Do not harass anyone. Do not contact anyone in my name. Read it. Share it. Send receipts, evidence, witnesses. Put eyes on the record.
You made it to the end
Most people quit at the headline. You didn’t.
So don’t stop here. Pick one.
Read the book
Fighting Shadows is the whole story in my own words: the road into January 6, the D.C. jail, and the fight to get the record out.See the book
Follow the case
The record is still being written. Get one email when something new drops on it.
Hire Ryan
I built this site. Want one that brings your business real leads? Start with a free 30-minute call.See the services
Tap how this hits you. No signup, everyone sees the count
71
Views
0
Likes
0
Comments
0
Shares
Share it. Every share puts more eyes on the record.



Comments
Speak here
Create an account to comment.
This is where people can say what gets buried or cancelled elsewhere. Comments are signed-only, moderated, and tied to a real profile so the record stays usable.
No approved comments yet. Create an account and put the first opinion on the record.